The Fed's subsidization of the American economy is over. The era of cheap
money is at an end. Interest rates have ratcheted up again in England, following
increases in Australia and China, so the long overdue rate increase in the
United States was no surprise. With interest rates at the lowest in recorded
history, America's net national savings rate dropped to less than 2% of GDP
as they borrowed with wild abandon. For three years, US interest rates have
been in negative territory as the Americans pursued a cheap money policy. As
such, further rate increases are inevitable which would expose the vulnerability
of America's financial center causing a further large devaluation of the dollar.
And with the election looming in the fall, a cheerleading Fed reluctantly removed
the punch bowl.
A Flood Of Red Ink
For some time now we raised concerns about this environment of unsustainable
low interest rates, believing that the glut of dollars would eventually feed
rising prices. Record household debt together with record government twin deficits
have made the US economy highly sensitive to the impact of higher interest
rates. The United States is the world's biggest capital importer and net debtor.
And now, even a small uptick in interest rates were enough to cause both the
stock market and housing markets to swoon on concerns about the overly indebted
consumer and financial institutions that financed this orgy of spending. Questions
are asked of even the "too big to fail" Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Of more
concern, is that while the consumer has retrenched, the Federal Government
has not, and is still running huge budgetary deficits.
The
deficits are the dollar's Achilles heel. To date, the dollar has lost 15 percent
of its value. The US current account deficit widened to $145 billion in the
first quarter and a record $55.8 billion in June. The current account deficit,
a broad measure of how much more the US is spending than taking in, is over
5 percent of GDP rising to over half a trillion dollars. The deficit reflects
the fact that Americans are spending more than they earn and their robust economy
is sucking in imports at a greater pace. Under President Bush the budget has
swung from a surplus to a deficit in only one term - a swing of 700 billion.
To balance its books, the US depends on the largesse of foreigners and must
attract more than $2.0 billion of net investment each day to cover the current
account shortfall. In the past, foreigners were piling up US assets at a huge
pace led by Asian economies intervening to prevent their currencies rising
further against the US dollar. In 1993, foreign holdings accounted for 20 percent
of US debt today. Foreign investors own almost half or $1.75 trillion of the
$3.76 trillion of marketable treasury debt.
Recent data shows overseas interest in US equities waned but after four consecutive
monthly declines, purchases picked up slightly in June. Lacking the necessary
pool of savings, the Americans are dependant on massive lending from the rest
of the world. The monstrous US trade deficit must be matched by a corresponding
surplus elsewhere.
Central
banks also slowed their dollar purchases in the latest quarter and there was
a collapse in demand for treasuries. In May, foreign purchases of US securities
were down 26 percent from April, the fourth consecutive monthly decline. Japan,
holding 16 percent of US Treasuries, bought $20.1 billion of Treasuries in
the months of April and May in contrast to average monthly purchases of $25
billion last year. We believe this outsourcing of the financing of the US economy
is over, with perilous consequences for the dollar.
And now, the US dollar beset by global security concerns, spiking oil prices
and the crushing weight of the twin deficits, has come under renewed selling
pressure as the increase in the current account deficit and jobless numbers
sent foreign investors scurrying into other major currencies and gold. The
bulk of the selling came from hedge funds reversing their "carry trade". We
believe the declining inflows will ripple across the globe.
The Implications Of Living In A China-centric World
The deteriorating trend in net US inflows suggests a growing reluctance by
foreign private investors and central banks to shoulder this burden. Until
now, Asian central banks were " the lenders of last resort". That has stopped.
And, foolish politically inspired duties on China's furniture manufacturers
is due to spark a reciprocal action. China has an increasing imbalance of trade
and financial surpluses, piling up more than $400 billion in US Treasuries
and has made moves to diversify into euros and more recently gold. In June,
China purchased a net $700 million of treasuries, down from $3.1 billion the
previous month.
China's
voracious appetite for raw materials has caused huge price spikes raising concerns
whether the price moves are sustainable. China has become a major player, with
total trade expected to top $1,000 billion up from $851 billion last year,
surpassing Japan as the third largest market. Indeed, the threat of a slowdown
in China was enough to cause the global stock markets to selloff. As outlined
in our last report, The China Syndrome, we believed the fears of a slowdown
were greatly exaggerated. China is on the path for another 9% plus growth -
it's not even a speed bump. China's imports are up a whopping 50 percent in
the first half of this year due to a 40 percent increase in crude imports to
2.45 million b/d. Bank lending in June rose 16.3 percent. Industrial production
rose 15.5 percent in July. While the world is focusing on China's growth prospects,
investors appear to have missed the implications of this growth. China has
accumulated large surpluses and a major part of US indebtedness, making it
a world player in the financial markets.
Dollar Blocs, Euro Blocs, and Yuan Blocs
China's emergence as a superpower has not only helped Japan pull out of its
ten year doldrum, it has been the driver for the emergence of the Far East
as a super economy. And there is talk of a common Asian currency like the Euro
to facilitate trade and investment. In essence, a common Asian currency would
reduce currency risk and the dependence on US dollar, further undermining the
greenback.
China's efforts to go from a state-owned and run enterprise to a more market
economy has come at a cost. For example, its banking sector is in need of restructuring
and there is still much to do about corporate governance. Nonetheless, the
world is now discovering what it is like to live in a China-centric world.
In 2003, China consumed 7 percent of the world's crude oil, 31 percent of its
coal, 30 percent of its iron ore, almost 20 percent of its steel, 25 percent
of its aluminum and 40 percent of its cement. No wonder foreign investment
surged into China, making it the largest recipient of the funds in the world,
exceeding the United States. China is now one of the world's twin economic
engines, alongside the United States. While a new superpower has emerged, the
old superpower, the United States is ageing.
For three years, a mixture of cyclical and structural factors has influenced
the US dollar. A major part of the decline is due to the imbalance of Chinese
production on the supply side and American consumption on the demand side.
China is a powerhouse of exports, until their consumers take up the slack,
the Chinese are dependent on America's insatiable appetite for goods. Here
is the rub. Once the Chinese become confident in their own markets and the
Asian countries begin to learn to rely on themselves and their markets , there
won't be a need for America. Why then, will they need all those reserves of
depreciating dollars?
The Golden Constant
After reaching a 16 year high, gold retrenched into a narrow trading range
between $380- $410 an ounce, as the dollar recorded a "dead cat" bounce against
other currencies. Gold is negatively correlated with the dollar. Is the party
over? Not yet!
Investors are concerned that higher rates to prop the dollar will also hurt
gold. A weak dollar goes hand in hand with higher rates. But higher rates and
a weaker dollar also are inflationary. Three years after the business cycle
peaked, the US economy is growing in fits and starts with an inflationary bias.
Inflation has reared its head, due to the tremendous amount of liquidity injected
into the system, in part to get the economy on track in time for the November
elections. Until recently, inflation was low and falling. The oil price hit
yet another peak at $46 a barrel reflecting a combination of strong demand,
tight supplies and increased risk premiums. Commodities have turned around
as tight inventories and strong demand have caused another spike in prices.
Inflation is back.
In the past there was another parallel period, between today's deficits and
the deficits of the seventies. In the seventies, the deficits surged with a
war in Vietnam, an oil crisis and a surge in global inflation. The Fed Fund
rate increased a net 14 times from 4.5 percent to 20 percent. Inflation soared
to 20 percent and the dollar fell 70 percent. Gold moved from $35 an ounce
to $850 per ounce. Today, the deficits are even larger and we have only begun
gold's second leg. The dollar has fallen only 15 percent so $510 per ounce
continues to be only an interim target.
Gold's
bull markets are normally underpinned by a pickup in investment demand, then
finds support from fabrication demand. Fabricators, build their holdings during
corrections. Through the 1996 to 2001 bear market, fabricator demand picked
up. When gold entered the bull market, fabricated demand actually declined
because fabricators expected gold prices to pull back. But instead investment
demand picked up due to heightened geo-political tensions, Chinese buying and
large gold derivative inflows. Meanwhile industrial demand exceeded the western
world's mine production. Central bank selling also slowed down and the new
pact will limit central bank sales to 500 tonnes a year for another five years.
De-hedging was also a big factor. Barrick, Placer and Cambior reduced their
hedges in the latest quarter. Both Placer and Barrick have more than three
years sold forward so they are expected to continue to deliver into their hedges.
De-hedging has a positive impact on prices and producers are expected to continue
to be among the biggest buyers of gold as they reverse their bloated hedge
books.
Gold is unlike other commodities in that it cannot rust, deteriorate or spoil.
Gold does not inflate like paper currencies. The supply of gold worldwide increased
by about 2 percent per year, or about the same rate as the increase in the
world's population. Compare that against the dramatic increase in the supply
of US dollars. It is no wonder that gold as a discipline for central banks
went out the window in 1971. In 1971, President Nixon severed the final link
between the dollar and gold. The global monetary base grew by 55 percent between
1949 and 1969 - an average of 2.2 percent a year. Since 1969, the monetary
base has grown four times by 1900 percent or 9.7 percent per year.
Gold does not pay interest. As such, misguided central bankers have been loaning
or selling gold reserves in order to generate income. The gold bears have calculated
gold's value over a hundred years versus treasury bill and found gold lacking
since it pays no interest. However, those same analysts should look at the
Seventies, when gold increased from $35 an ounce to $850 an ounce. Gold increased
about 24 times or 2400 percent for an annual increase of 34 percent. To be
sure there were no bonds during that period that returned 34 percent. Gold
is indeed the ultimate hedge asset. Don't look now, but gold is rising. To
repeat, $510 an ounce is only an interim target. Gold is a good thing to have.
Companies
Agnico-Eagle Mines Ltd.
Agnico-Eagle recorded a second quarter of $0.11 per share up from $0.05 per
share due to higher production of 65,233 ounces versus 60,157 ounces. The
LaRonde gold producer in northwestern Quebec has shown the street it has
turned the corner with its third impressive quarter. In addition, the mill
ran at a record 8,300 tonnes per day, up 8 percent and the company is on
track to produce about 295,000 ounces this year. More importantly, the company
is spending about $30 million on the underground development at its Lapa
property about eleven kilometers east of LaRonde. Lapa will be in production
in 2008 producing 125,000 ounces of gold at a cash cost of $175 an ounce.
Agnico-Eagle is also carrying out studies at Goldex in order to bring that
deposit into production. And finally, Agnico-Eagle has seven drills working
underground at LaRonde as part the largest exploration program in Canada.
We continue to like the shares here.
Barrick Gold Corp.
Barrick Gold reported second quarter earnings of $0.06 per share in line with
consensus estimates. However, a large part of those earnings were due to
a tax credit and derivative gains. Barrick produced less gold in the quarter
due to falling production from Pierina and Goldstrike. Barrick also unwound
850,000 ounces at a cost of $26 million and now has 84 percent of its reserves
unhedged. However Barrick still has more than three and half years of production
hedged. At the end of June, the hedge book stood at 13.9 million ounces with
a negative mark-to market value of $1.4 billion. To offset a flat production
profile, Barrick provided more clarity on the development of five new mines
in Argentina, Chile, Peru, Tanzania and Australia. However the big "on again
and off again" Pascua price tag went up and the project is not expected to
come on stream until 2009. Barrick now estimates that the capital cost of
Pascua at almost $1.5 billion and that is before taxes and other fiscal arrangements
including environmental. More promising in the near term is production coming
from Alto Chicama, Veladero and Tuluwaka. Nonetheless, the problem with Barrick,
like most senior producers - is how to replace quickly depleting reserves.
The senior producers are stuck on a treadmill and cannot quickly replace
their reserves due to the shortage of world-class deposits. As such, we prefer
the more growth oriented middle-sized producers who are potential targets
themselves.
Cambior Inc.
Cambior reported earnings of $0.01 per share reflecting a major contribution
from the new Rosebel mine in Suriname, which came on stream of February of
this year. Cambior produced 193,000 ounces in total with Gross Rosebel producing
74,100 ounces at a cash cost of $160. Significantly, Cambior also reduced
its hedges by 281,000 ounces in the second quarter leaving a balance of only
207,000 ounces or 5 percent of reserves. Cambior is expected to continue
to reduce its hedges. Cambior is consolidating its assets and excess cash
flow will likely be directed towards smaller acquisitions. While acquisition
of the balance of Aurizon makes sense, Cambior does not appear to want to
do that and in fact may sell its holding. We view Cambior as a hold at this
time.
Crystallex International Corporation
Crystallex unveiled its second phase expansion that will double the output
from 10.2 million ounce Las Cristinas project in Venezuela to 500,000 ounces.
The base case of 20,000 tonnes per day would produce 311,000 ounces at a
cash cost of $144 per ounce in 2006. Detailed engineering and environmental
work is being carried out by SNC Lavelin Engineering & Constructors.
The revised 40,000 tpd model lowers cash cost to $190 per ounce and raises
the capital cost to $266 million. Crystallex is currently drilling an 18
infill hole program, which could add about 2 million ounces to its proven
and probable reserves as it drills more closely spaced holes in the proposed
pit. Having been granted the "land" permit, Crystallex expects to receive
the final permit before the end of this year and financing will be in place
by the same time. Consequently we expect the company to break ground by the
end of this year, which would attract investor interest. We continue to recommend
this undervalued producer. Buy.
Goldcorp Inc.
Goldcorp has one of the strongest balance sheets with $365 million of working
capital, no debt and over 117,000 ounces of gold in inventory. Goldcorp has
so far delineated almost 6 million ounces of reserves and the flagship Red
Lake mine expansion in northwestern Ontario is expected to cost over $100
million. Goldcorp has the balance sheet to handle this expansion easily and
is expected to spend about $30 million this year. Goldcorp reported earnings
of $0.05 of per share with production in the second quarter totaling 138,000
ounces at a cash cost $116 per ounce. Earnings were below estimates due to
the retention of 33 percent of Goldcorp's production. Goldcorp is comfortable
stockpiling gold believing both gold is money and confidence in the gold
price. At Red Lake, Goldcorp is spending more than $50 million but the shaft
development is going slow. The shaft is currently at 1250 feet and is expected
to reach total depth at 7150 feet by 2006. By then, Goldcorp should be producing
over 700,000 ounces. Goldcorp has also taken some of its excess cash flow
and made investments in strategic juniors giving it exposure to potentially
large exploration plays. For example, Goldcorp has accumulated about 14 percent
of White Knight Resources, which is the second largest player surrounding
Placer Dome's Cortez Hill discovery (see report: Placer Dome Has A New Discovery
With A White Knight In The Wings). We continue to recommend Goldcorp for
the Red Lake mine, its astute management and rock solid balance sheet.
Kinross Gold Corporation
Kinross reported an excellent second quarter of $0.02 a share versus a loss
last year. In addition, Canada's third largest gold company will produce
1.7 million ounces from its twelve mines at a cash cost of $230 per ounce.
Kinross has $200 million of cash with a working capital position of $270
million at the end of June. The company has recently acquired positions in
Cumberland, Anatolia Minerals and White Knight giving it excellent exploration
potential. Kinross expects to explore around key mines Fort Knox, Round Mountain
and Kubaka. Kettle River will come on stream this year extending Kinross
reserve life. Kinross is hedge free and is well levered to the gold price.
Buy.
Meridian Gold Inc.
Meridian reported exceptional earnings of $0.10 a share due to the El Penon
mine in Chile which produced 82,000 ounces of gold in the quarter up from
78,000 ounces. Total cash cost was at $50 per ounce and the elimination of
a drag on earnings from recently sold Jerritt Canyon helped results. Mill
through-put at El Penon reached record levels in June. The exceptional high
grade Dorada vein was extended to 1.2 kilometres in strike length and underground
access to Dorada was initiated. Meridian should be mining Dorada high grade
material within a year and a half. Meridian has cash of $210 million and
should produce 310,000 ounces of gold at a cash cost between $50-$60 an ounce.
We like Meridian shares at current levels and believe there is nothing in
the shares for Esquel which is stalled at this time. Meridian continues to
work with the local community to reverse its stance. We believe that a thawing
in the relationship is inevitable and thus there is interesting upside to
Meridian shares if there is a move towards putting the Esquel project into
production. Buy.
Miramar Mining Corporation
Miramar shares were hard hit following disappointing news that the permitting
process with the Nunavut board has delayed bringing on the Doris North project.
There is only a twelveweek window and the need to assemble and bring equipment
to the north afforded little opportunity for another delay in the permitting
process so construction cannot begin until 2005. Consequently, Doris North
won't be brought on stream until late 2006 pending at the earliest. Meanwhile
Miramar closed the Giant mine because every ounce Miramar produced was at
a loss. Consequently, the loss of production is a plus since Miramar will
have more cash flow to work with. From an exploration point of view further
news from Hope Bay and Goose Lake this summer should result in limiting the
downside.
Placer Dome Inc.
Placer Dome reported second quarter results of $0.08 per share on gold production
of 908,000 ounces at a cash cost of $229 per ounce. For this year, Placer
Dome is in line to produce 3.6 million ounces of gold and 400 million pounds
of copper at a cash cost $230 per ounce. Like other senior producers, Placer's
problem is the replacement of reserves. Development work at Getchell's Turquoise
Ridge is slower than the company expected. South Deep in South Africa continues
to be a disappointment producing only 51,000 ounces at a cash cost of $399
per ounce. South Deep remains an albatross for Placer and the South African
rand is going the wrong way. Noteworthy is that until the shaft is deepened
there will be no impact on production which is a problem since the bulk of
Placer's reserves are in South Africa.
On a positive note, however, Placer released an update on Cortez Hills in
Nevada, which could be a company maker. Placer boosted reserves at Cortez Hills
from 3.2 million ounces to 4.5 million ounces and the company expects to complete
a feasibility study by year-end. The Cortez Hill discovery is close to the
Pipeline facility and this high-grade deposit can be brought on stream fairly
quickly. As of June 30th, 94 holes were completed with assays received from
72 holes. So far the high-grade zone is open to the west and down depth and
the company has yet to define the limits of this discovery. Of interest is
that there is a possibility that this deposit can link up with nearby Pediment,
which would add to the reserve picture. While it is still early days, we believe
Cortez could add about $2.00 per share to Placer's NAV. At Pueblo Viejo in
the Dominican Republic, Placer also gave clarity to its program. Pueblo Viejo
is a refractory deposit and the company expects to produce a prefeasibilty
study by the end of this year. Placer like Barrick has reduced its hedges but
the company still has almost 10 million ounces under hedge, which is three
years of production hedged - too high. The mark-to-market loss is $307 million.
With the exciting Cortez Hills discovery and the prospect of bringing Pueblo
Viejo on stream, Placer has offset the difficulties in South Africa and we
recommend the shares at current levels.
Richmont Mines Inc.
Richmont has started the ramp at East Amphi in Quebec at a cost between $6-$7
million. The ramp should be finished by early fall and thus development work
could begin. East Amphi will provide 250,000 ounces to Richmont's book. In
Newfoundland, the company has begun drilling at Valentine and a 2,000 foot
program will look for additional reserves to be processed at Richmont's facility.
Richmont's shares have corrected and with only 16 million shares outstanding,
the company is well levered to the gold price. Richmont should produce between
65,000 and 70,000 ounces this year and in 2006, a doubling of output is expected.
With a working capital position of $30 million, no debt nor hedges, the stock
is undervalued with earnings expected to be $0.32 this year. We like this
junior producer here.
Click to enlarge table: