Gold pulled back last month but held above the critical support level at $430
an ounce. We are now getting a rally triggered in part by Hurricane Katrina
and Koizumi's election victory. The real question is whether or not this is
the end of the decline or the beginning of the resumption of the bull market
that will see gold surpassing the last peak at $850 an ounce.
We believe that gold will rise over $500 an ounce this year as investors dump
US assets in response to a falling dollar, economic woes following the clean-up
of Katrina and America's growing indebtedness. The once powerful locomotive
has become the little train that can't. Gold has surged 43 percent over the
past three years while the greenback has lost over 50 percent during the same
period. America's problems and vulnerability will boost gold's appeal as a
haven in uncertain times.
And like oil, gold supplies are tight. Gold production in South Africa, the
world's largest producer, is expected to decline again this year due to increasing
production costs and a strong rand. South African output fell 12 percent in
July and this year will fall to 300 tons down from 342.7 tons, the lowest in
74 years. Meanwhile, the World Gold Council reported global demand in the second
quarter for gold jewellery totalling 949 tones, up 14 percent form a year ago
particularly from India. Demand from China increased 12 percent. Gold's fundamentals
can't get any better.
New Orleans is sinking
America's worst natural disaster exposed its vulnerability. There were not
enough helicopter, soldiers or National Guardsmen to save New Orleans from
becoming Atlantis. Why? The generals were right - America's resources are tied
up in Iraq.
Just as a benign event as the "missing anchovies" off the coast of Peru, heralded
the great inflation of the 70s, so will Katrina usher a sea change in the financial
landscape. When the Peruvian anchovies went missing, the Japanese became big
buyers of soybeans touching off a chain reaction that saw a big increase in
agricultural prices, which led to the double-digit inflation surge. Inflation
never showed up at once. It was first seen in the runup in gold, the anchovies
went missing, commodities moved up, then oil quadrupled. Gold surged to a record
peak at $850 an ounce. Today, gold prices have resumed their three-year climb.
The CRB future index is at another record high. Oil has tripled in price. Every
commodity has a tight supply/demand bias. Oh yes, it is the peak harvest season
and farmers must ship their crops down the Mississippi...but how and when?
Katrina's effects will touch every aspect of the US economy.
An ill wind blows
Hurricane Katrina's continuing disruption of the Gulf Coast refineries, pipelines
and ports raises the prospect of a 1970s energy crisis. And unlike, the 70s,
this does not involve just oil. New Orleans is the largest energy hub for refining,
natural gas, pipelines and electricity. Energy prices have already spiked,
long gas lines have been reported and there is talk of heating oil shortages
this winter. Its only going to get worse with at least 5% of US refinery capacity
still shutdown at a time when there is no slack in the world's refining system
nor new capacity to bring on stream. There has not been a single refinery built
in the United States for more than a quarter of a century.
Even before Katrina, oil was high, not because of supply shortages but because
of excess demand and the flow of hot money, betting on even higher prices.
A supply shock will now be more damaging. While in the long run, the laws of
supply and demand will take hold as more supplies are found, $40 oil is now
part of our past. To be sure, the spike in oil prices will ensure higher energy
and food prices, and the core rate of inflation has already risen to 3.7% in
July up from the 2%. Inflation is a dynamic beast, once released from the bottle,
it cannot go back in.
Global Bubbles, Toil and Trouble
Ten years ago, the tech boom exploded with internet stocks reaching the sky
only to collapse with a handful of survivors. Today retiring Fed Chairman Greenspan,
missing the stock market bubble, is now warning about the end of housing market's
five-year run. That these bubbles are Greenspan's creations are lost on most
advisors. Mr. Greenspan's easy monetary policies has created the biggest housing
bubble ever, leading to a huge increase in consumer spending as people borrowed
on the equity of their houses. And because of the US savings shortfall to finance
these deficits, Mr. Greenspan sold debt to foreigners.
Amid this increase in debt, investors missed a new bubble formed, oil. Oil
prices have slipped to $63 a barrel, not far from the record $70.85 after the
storm. Investors appear buoyed by the lack of an oil shock owing to the underlying
resiliance of the American economy. Wrong. We believe that the current run-up
in crude oil prices in the aftermath of storm will cause that oil shock. History
shows that following the last two oil price spikes of the 1970s, discretionary
spending contracted, setting the stage for consumer-led recessions. And America's
indebtedness has made it more vulnerable to not only financial shocks but also
oil shocks. What happens when you combine both?
Achilles Heel - Billions in spending
After Katrina, the US budget deficit will hit a record $400 million despite
an improvement in tax revenues. Billions in spending are planned and rebuilding
will cost more than the Wars of Afghanistan and Iraq combined. The US had outsized
spending requirements before Katrina, needing to attract more than $3 billion
in net inflows in each working day, to cover the large and growing current
account deficit. The spiralling deficit is being matched by growing current
account surpluses in Asia and oil exporting countries. And with few signs of
narrowing, the current account deficit could reach $1 trillion in 2006. History
shows us that this is not sustainable.
So far the capital inflows have allowed the Americans to live beyond their
means since domestic savings are near zero. As a consequence the US economy
is suffering from twin imbalances. Domestic spending has caused the budgetary
deficit to grow again, fueled by tax cuts, the Iraq war and now Katrina and
with the huge trade deficit as far as the eye can see, how are they to be financed?
By foreigners again?
Foreign central banks are buying fewer dollars, rebalancing the reserve portfolios
by diversifying and buying more non-dollar denominated assets. Japan, the biggest
overseas holder of US treasuries, holds more than $700 billion, while the Chinese
hold $250 billion. The UK holds more than $140 billion of treasuries. However,
in the first quarter of this year, foreign investors raised their holdings
of British government bonds by $18 billion, financing over one quarter of outstanding
issuances. China and Malaysia abandoned their dollar pegs and are managing
their currencies to a basket of currencies tied to their trading partners.
The Russians are considering lessening their dependence on the dollar. Shortly
after the death of King Fahd, the dollar plunged in part to rumours that the
Saudi Arabian monetary authority was swapping dollars for euros, purchasing
billions of euros. The move was rumoured to be a prelude of a plan to follow
China and shift from a dollar peg to a basket arrangement, diversifying out
of dollars. Ominously, US data shows that in June, overseas investors only
bought $7.9 million of US treasures, the lowest level since September 2003.
So far the diversification has been orderly but dollar flights are never that.
The financial world just had a margin call
After Katrina, the financial world just had a margin call. Katrina will be
the most expensive national disaster ever. We believe the economic fallout
will reverberate well into the future from the property and business insurers
to the commodities traders to the hedge fund manager, all of whom are the big
users of these credit derivatives.
Hurricane Katrina is such an example of how life can upset the best laid plans,
projections and hedging strategies. Left unsaid is following the aftermath
of Katrina, what will happen to America's financial markets? This natural disaster
will turn into a financial one as well. Preliminary estimates suggest that
insured losses from the storm could exceed $60 billion with actual damage to
be three times that. The hurricane will lead to billions of dollars in liabilities
making the storm the most the industry has paid for any other natural disaster
in the country's history. While the prevailing view is that there is little
systemic damage to the stock markets, Katrina has hit the insurance industry
at its most vulnerable period since that industry is still paying off claims
from earlier storms as well as dealing with the SEC and Mr. Spitzer. Reinsurers
to hedge risk are major users of the complex financial derivative market. And,
a number of hedge funds attracted by the returns entered the reinsurance market.
Over the past decade, credit derivatives were issued as products that allowed
investors to hedge themselves against risk. This "funny money" market exploded
in use as financial conglomerates, especially larger global banking institutions
accounted for more and more of the derivative market. Never have so few controlled
so much, concentrating risk reminiscence of the "too big to fail" institutions
in the "go-go" period.
The amount of financial derivatives traded rose 11 percent in the second quarter
to total $372 trillion or more than 10 times the global economy. It is these
financial instruments that were supposed to be the" levees" against the floodwaters
of financial disaster. The derivative market provided the hedges against financial
losses for many financial conglomerates. With housing and oil in a boom phase,
the derivative bubble has grown even faster. On September 15th, the Federal
Reserve of New York invited 14 of the major participants in the credit derivatives
market to a meeting concerning $8.4 trillion in "unconfirmed" trades. And,
the Financial Services Authority, the main UK Securities regulator has requested
similar information from UK banks. It seems that regulators on both sides of
the ocean are assessing the growing risks of the infrastructure of the credit
derivative market. Backlogs, unconfirmed transactions, delayed settlements
are part of the back office problem but now total billions in risks.
Gold - Hedge against declines in other investments
We believe that gold is an excellent alternative as a hedge against declines
in other investments, particularly as the series of aforementioned bubbles
pop. Gold historically has been an effective hedge against inflation, a prudent
hedge in portfolios against the systemic unwinding of the dollar and a barometer
of financial stress.
Mr. Bush has become the biggest spender since Lyndon Johnson's "gas and butter":
spending for the Great Society and the Vietnam war which touched off the 1970s
inflation. Investors have become concerned about the United States, its fiat
currency and now its financial system. And just as the missing anchovies were
the benign event that ushered in the Great Inflation in the seventies so will
Katrina trigger a sea change in economic activity. So amid a vulnerable financial
system beset by rising deficits, bloated government expenditures, low savings,
sky-high housing prices, a falling dollar and a lack of confidence in other
currencies, gold will be the prime beneficiary and is the sole levee against
the incoming floodwaters.
Recommendations
Gold stocks were again disappointing performers in relation to bullion, due
to poor operating results as result of rising costs. Despite a decline in hedging,
the mark-to-market positions plunged further into the red with the higher bullion
price. More importantly, most producers have not been able to successfully
replace reserves and thus are stuck on a treadmill. For some time, we have
recommended the intermediate group of players because of their superior production
profiles together with advanced development projects. We continue to recommend
Agnico-Eagle, Meridian, Goldcorp and Kinross.
We also believe the industry itself will continue the trend towards consolidation
because of the lack of reserve replacement. We are about to embark on a re-run
of mergers and acquisitions. In addition, there has been a dearth of exploration
news as companies continue to spend on development rather than for exploring
for gold. Analysis of the industry's capital spending shows that they are spending
more on development prospects and not enough real grassroots exploration. Until
the industry spends money on exploration they will have to content themselves
by eating their own and ultimately that is even more bullish for the gold price
but not for the companies.
Agnico-Eagle Mines Ltd
Agnico-Eagle's bid for all of Swedish miner Riddarhyttan Resources AB appears
dead in the water since a significant minority have rejected the $130 million
paper bid. Agnico-Eagle has said they will not increase its bid for the Finnish
deposit. We believe that should Agnico-Eagle be unsuccessful, the shares
will ironically perform better due to the lack of paper dilution. Agnico-Eagle
has enough on its development plate with the advanced development of Goldex,
Lapa and of course LaRonde. At LaRonde, the company is benefiting from higher
by-product prices. We like the shares here.
Bema Gold Corp
Bema announced a $119 million bought deal and $400 million debt financing and
to develop the high-grade Kupol gold/silver project in Russia's Far East.
Bema released a feasibility study outlining positive economics in line with
expectations and production will start in mid 2008. With the bulk of value
of Bema in 75 percent owned Kupol, every burp will be important to Bema's
stock price. Refugio in Chile will contribute a full year's production next
year offsetting the drag of Petrex in South Africa. Consequently with the
bulk of Bema's asset tied to Kupol and Julietta, Bema has a very attractive
Russian base and we recommend purchase.
Eldorado Gold Corporation
Eldorado shares have been acting better as the opening of the Kisladag open
pit mine in Turkey gets closer. While the start-up is delayed till the new
year, construction of this huge mine is on track. Eldorado's Kisladag mine
will produce 164,000 ounces, paving the way for Eldorado to develop the Efencukuru
deposit with almost 1 million ounces of reserves in western Turkey. With
mines in Brazil and Turkey, Eldorado has added a third leg through the acquisition
of Afcan Minerals whose principal asset is the Tanijianshan gold project
in northwest China. We recommend purchase of this junior producer.
Goldcorp Inc
Goldcorp reported excellent results due in part to the sale of the bullion
inventory accumulated by former CEO Robert McEwen. Also, the company unfortunately
will no longer stockpile its production from the Red Lake mine. The new management's
task is to concentrate on existing production as well as bring Amapari in
Brazil into full production. The sale of the bullion inventory and various
stakes in junior gold miners boosted Goldcorp's results, masking potentially
negative news such as increasing operating cost and additional delays over
the sinking of the Red Lake shaft. However, with a broad asset base and a
rock solid balance sheet, Goldcorp is well placed to pursue its 2 million
ounce per annum production goal.
Kinross Gold Corp
Kinross was able to report its quarterly production in the second quarter but
financials were again withheld due to the SEC review. Kinross has submitted
a letter to the SEC in response to the Comment Letter, and thus daylight
is in sight. We suspect that once the SEC gives the green light, Kinross
will be able file its results following a re-statement of its historical
earnings and goodwill. There is no question that there will be a hefty restatement
of the goodwill portion relating to the TVX and Echo Bay acquisition, however,
such a statement would not impair earnings or cash flow. More importantly
Kinross will be able to file its financials and complete the acquisition
of Crown Resources.
We believe that SEC approval will be a catalyst for a jump in the shares allowing
management the time to look at other acquisitions in particular the merger
with Polyus, the Russian gold subsidiary of Norilsk. As for operations, Paracutu
in Brazil continues to perform well. Kinross will likely boost its reserves
at Paracutu, following an expanded exploration budget. Paracutu is a company
builder. At Round Mountain, the Company has successfully boosted reserves.
Kinross has excellent leverage to the gold price and a higher gold price would
allow Kinross to boost reserves at Round Mountain and Fort Knox in Alaska.
We recommend the shares here.
Placer Dome Inc
Placer Dome's results were a disaster as the company reported a second quarter
$7 million loss due to increased costs, hedging losses and non-cash charge
with respect to the company's Australian assets. At the Porgera Mine, Placer's
share of a production in the quarter dropped 11 percent and costs were higher.
In South Africa, the South Deep/Western Areas joint venture continues to be
hit with delays and higher costs - the development bill keeps on rising. Its
partner Western Areas recently announced an 18 percent drop in reserves or
10 million ounces to a total of 45 million ounces due to the fact that the
reserves are not mineable. Amazingly, Placer Dome has remained quiet on this
expected reduction but its share is 5 million ounces. For sometime we warned
that too much of Placer Dome's value and reserves were based in South Africa
and the stock should trade at a discount to its peers. With an expected reserve
reduction, rising costs and ongoing disputes with its partner, we believe that
investors would be pouring good money after bad money here. For example, phase
I was supposed to cost $500 million and phase II was to increase reserves but
would cost a whopping $1.2 billion. So far the project is two and half years
behind schedule and the South Deep joint venture has not performed up to expectations.
Meanwhile, at the Cerro Casale open pit project in Chile, the company has
not disclosed how it proposes to finance the $1.3 billion price tag for its
partner, Bema. Amid all this bad news, Placer also downplayed the exploration
potential at Cortez Hill with a lack of definitive news and released very little
on the Pueblo Viejo project in the Dominican Republic (it is our understanding
that the price tag has increased). The Cortez Hill play could be a company
builder for most companies but somehow Placer Dome is closed lipped on this.
Placer Dome is going to need huge capital outlays and we are not confident
in its ability to spend this wisely.
Click
to open larger image in new window:

Analyst Disclosure
| Company Name |
Trading Symbol |
*Exchange |
Disclosure code |
| Barrick Gold |
ABX |
T |
1 |
| Bema Gold |
BGO |
T |
1 |
| Crystallex |
KRY |
T |
1,5 |
Disclosure Key: 1=The Analyst, Associate or member of
their household owns the securities of the subject issuer. 2=Maison Placements
Canada Inc. and/or affiliated companies beneficially own more than 1% of any
class of common equity of the issuers. 3=<Employee name> who is an officer
or director of Maison Placements Canada Inc. or it's affiliated companies serves
as a director or advisory Board Member of the issuer. 4=In the previous 12
months a Maison Analyst received compensation from the subject company. 5=Maison
Placements Canada Inc. has managed co-managed or participated in an offering
of securities by the issuer in the past 12 months. 6=Maison Placements Canada
Inc. has received compensation for investment banking and related services
from the issuer in the past 12 months. 7=Maison is making a market in an equity
or equity related security of the subject issuer. 8=The analyst has recently
paid a visit to review the material operations of the issuer. 9=The analyst
has received payment or reimbursement from the issuer regarding a recent visit.
T-Toronto; V-TSX Venture; NQ-NASDAQ; NY-New York Stock Exchange