Geopolitical shockwaves have fractured along fundamental fault lines. The
hostilities in the Middle East intensified on two fronts. The Israeli-Palestinian
conflict spread to Lebanon and now has drawn in Iran, through its proxy Hezbollah.
To be sure, nobody can claim the moral high ground here but the undercurrent
is that as long this festers there will be no progress on other fronts, making
investors more worried, particularly when oil prices hit a new record. The
growing hostilities also increased market volatility and the rollercoaster
ride caused oil and gold to hit higher levels.
The West has been reduced to passive observers. The rise of Hezbollah, a Shiite
organization, armed and bankrolled by Shiite-led Iran is causing alarm in Sunni-led
Saudi Arabia, Jordan and Egypt. Iran is also backing the Arab Shiite majority
in Iraq. Iran has replaced the US as the dominant power in the region. The
Americans and Israelis are caught in a sectarian split that threatens to engulf
all the Middle East. Israel and America appear poised to repeat the mistakes
of the past in Vietnam and Lebanon in 1982. Hezbollah's 34 day conflict with
Israel exposes not only longstanding hostilities but also the sectarian differences
among the Arabs, exposing centuries of enmity between the Sunni and Shia branches
of Islam. Democracy in the Middle East is paper-thin and the radical movements
have hijacked this process. The West and Israel are caught up in not only a
regional battle but a religious one as well and to a large extent unable to
stop the erosion of democracy.
Although 90 percent of the world's Muslims are Sunni the radical Shia Islamist
groups fear that America and Sunni Arab interests will ultimately coalesce
against them and the struggle inside Islam is the competition to carry the
flag for Arab nationalists. Shiite Iran is the common denominator supplying
the resources and arms. Iran holds the ultimate card - a nuclear stockpile?
No, Iran is the world's fourth largest exporter of oil, exporting a critical
2.4 million barrels of oil a day - the swing producer. Iran also straddles
the Straits of Hormuz - source of one fifth of the world's oil needs. Indeed
it's that concern that will drive oil and gold prices higher. The problem is
not a shortage of oil but the geo-political fear of the disruption of oil supplies.
Gold will be a good thing to have.
Top 15 Countries with Highest Proportion of
Shiites in the Population |
| Country |
Number of
Shiites |
Percent
Shiite% |
| Iran |
61,000,000 |
93 |
| Oman |
948,750 |
75 |
| Bahrain |
400,000 |
65 |
| Azerbaijan |
4,700,000 |
61 |
| Iraq |
11,000,000 |
55 |
| Lebanon |
1,370,000 |
40 |
| Yemen |
3,170,000 |
36 |
| Kuwait |
550,000 |
30 |
| Pakistan |
26,700,000 |
25 |
| Syria |
1,300,000 |
17 |
| United Arab Emirates |
400,000 |
16 |
| Turkey |
6,000,000 |
15 |
| Afghanistan |
3,560,000 |
15 |
| Saudi Arabia |
620,000 |
15 |
NOTE: This list is not based on the proportion of Muslims which
are Shiite, but on the proportion of Shiites in the total population.
Gold is the Currency of the Realm
In "Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest", a greedy pirate hunter, barks "loyalty
is no longer the currency realm". What is then, "the currency of the realm"?
The US dollar might have been the currency of the realm but that too is fading
in use. We believe that the new currency is gold. Gold was the currency of
the realm then, now and in the new future.
The United States, the sole global superpower has become the world's largest
debtor and its current account deficit was the second largest on record last
month. They are simply consuming more than they produce. America's credit card
is tapped out, running up another huge bill (almost 7 percent of American GDP),
using borrowed foreign money to pay for it every month. That debt has grown
at twice the rate of the United States' GDP. America, however has exceeded
its limit and is too deep in debt and despite the increase in interest rates,
foreigners are putting their money elsewhere.
China Provided Cheap Financing
China has provided cheap financing to Americans by buying huge amounts of
their treasury bonds allowing them to finance their mammoth twin deficits.
By unpegging the yuan, the Chinese will need fewer dollars, thus American interest
rates must rise as they attempt to replace foreign creditors. Unfortunately,
the Americans cannot finance the debt internally because they have zero savings.
America's problem is "made in America" and not a "made in China" problem. Following
the internet bust of the late nineties, Fed policymakers concluded that since
it was too hard to identify bubbles as they were inflating, it was best to
wait until they popped, then clean up the mess. That happened as the Fed dropped
interest rates from 6 percent to 1 percent. This encouraged a borrowing binge
and the resulting excess liquidity flowed into prices of assets such as homes,
rather than the traditional inflation hedges. Fed policy simply replaced the
internet bubble with the housing bubble. But seventeen interest rate hikes
later, all has changed.
In May, foreign central banks became net sellers of long term securities for
the first time in a year. There now appears to be a shift away from American
treasuries to eurodollars. Alternatives are available. For example, the Bank
of Italy lowered its US dollar holdings from 84 percent to 63 percent, shifting
to sterling which now makes up about 24 percent of Italy's reserves. The Chinese,
an emerging superpower, might not be so ready to recycle their dollars should
Senators Schumer and Graham reintroduce their tariff bill to Congress by September
30. And just when everybody forgot the March controversy over the Dubai Ports
World takeover, the United Arab Emirates reminded us of their political clout
by moving 10 percent of the UAEs' $229 billion foreign exchange reserves into
euros. Indeed, many of the Gulf countries have proposed to drop the dollar
peg and move to a floating exchange rate which would further weaken the US
dollar. America's Achilles heel is the massive transfer of wealth from the
developed world to superpower wannabes, the oil-rich Middle East and Russia.
America's Insatiable Appetite Leaves It Vulnerable
In a further sign of the dollar's diminished role as a reserve currency, the
United States has quietly ended its 10 year opposition to the establishment
of an Asian currency similar to the European currency (EU). Since Japan, China
and Taiwan hold the bulk of the world's reserves, the establishment of an Asian
currency unit is inevitable. In April the Treasury department reported that
foreign investors bought only $58.5 billion worth of US securities, the lowest
level in a year.
Russia has bought more gold and has been piling up petrodollars, making Russia
the third largest holder of foreign exchange in the world. By the end of July,
Russia had gold and foreign exchange reserves of $277 billion up from $180
billion at the beginning of the year. China once had a balance of payment surplus
of $100 billion in 2005 and today holds $975 billion. Saudi Arabia expects
to have $203 billion by the end of this year. Saudi Arabia is enjoying record
oil revenues of $20 billion a month. The petrodollars are now piling up and
rival the Asian cash hoard. According to the IMF, the current account surpluses
of Kuwait and Norway are $311 billion this year up from $242 billion, while
Asia's surplus will be down to $253 billion versus $263 billion last year.
The IMF also reported that from 1999 through 2005, revenues of OPEC nations
plus Russia totaled $2 trillion as the price of oil doubled during this period.
Indeed, Russia has been able to use those petrodollars to repay $22 billion
of debt owed to the Paris Club.
The problem, however is not the piling up of petrodollars, it is America's
insatiable appetite for energy and cheap financing. By saving too little, and
consuming too much, Americans have become too dependent on foreign investors,
and ironically on Iran.
Inflation Is Back
Gold has doubled in two years. When the dollar loses value, gold will resume
its uptrend. However, we believe the main driver of gold beyond $850 an ounce
this year will not be geo-political events but the return of inflation. Despite
Ben Bernanke's pronouncements, inflation is not a by-product of housing starts
or ebbing oil prices. Those are symptoms of inflation as is the rising cost
of mortgages, food, rents and taxes. While inflation has been subdued for the
last decade at 2.6 percent, the spike in ever-climbing oil price has resulted
in a jump in core inflation (ex: food and energy) to levels not seen in eleven
years.
With the May stock market meltdown, investors are looking who to blame? Rather
than a grand conspiracy among central banks, we believe the meltdown was simply
due to investor recognition of a new sea change in the marketplace. Investors
are recognizing a new problem. For some time, we cautioned investors about
the inflation in stock prices which came about from too much money chasing
too few stocks. Today the attendant liquidity created by the central banks
has gone into hard assets like commodities and into gold. With "real" interest
rates even now at relatively low levels, investors can still take advantage
of the "carry trade", particularly highly leveraged hedge funds that have been
going in and out of various markets. Indeed, the hedge funds are not the problem,
they are just a reflection of the problem and a product of the flood of easy
money.
To no surprise, base metal prices also moved in line with China's explosive
growth. Last year, global stainless steel production increased dramatically.
Stainless steel production accounts for about 70 percent of annual nickel demand.
Nickel stockpiles have fallen from 35,000 tonnes in February to less than 6,000
tonnes or one day's supply. The price of nickel hit a record and has increased
about 56 percent from mid-January. Copper is at two days supply. The explosion
of China and India has reshaped the global economic order changing the pace
of not only the financial markets but now the commodity markets.
Get Ready for the Food Inflation Bubble
Despite Ben Bernanke's reassuring words, inflation is back. Overall prices
rose by 0.2 percent in July, despite a temporary drop in energy prices. While
economists will play around with the numbers, prices increased to an annual
rate of 4.3 percent over the last twelve months and 5.2 percent for the last
three months. In fact, the US Bureau of Labour Statistics' calculation of the
consumer price index (CPI) is flawed as a leading indicator and more of a backward
looking indicator. Indeed the CPI is of little value as an oracle of how markets
interpret inflation data.
The real lead indicators are gold, commodities and currency markets. Gold
has risen 50 percent while the dollar has fallen 6 percent. Inflation is a
monetary phenomenon. And, more inflation allows the Fed to repay its indebtedness
with cheaper dollars. The Fed quietly ended the release of important M3 data
in March, removing a more accurate indicator of inflation. While investors
will not be able to study M3 anymore, the price of commodities and now agricultural
or "soft" commodities will more accurately reflect money inflation. Get ready
for food inflation.
SUVs or a Meal
Low inventories, strong demand and the highest prices in ten years. Yet another
base metal? No. The global heat wave and low stocks have pushed wheat prices
to ten year highs. Corn, soybeans, and barley are also increasing in prices.
And the US Agricultural Department (USDA) warned that the US spring wheat crop
was the worst in eighteen years because of the lack of moisture. US wheat stocks
are the lowest in eleven years. Soft commodities are moving in line with inflationary
expectations. And for those of us who are old enough, the warming of the ocean
has caused the anchovies to go missing off the coast of Peru, again. The last
time the anchovies went missing was in the seventies. Those missing anchovies
were a prelude to a double digit run in inflation as consumers replaced the
missing anchovies with soybeans and the inflation dominos fell after that.
The spike in oil and subsequent rise in commodities were blamed for the inflation
of the 70s. This time not only are the anchovies missing but the explosive
growth in biofuels has resulted in big increases in grain consumption which
is the main ingredient to make ethanol in Europe and Brazil.
While the May meltdown was sparked in part by central bank jawboning, we believe
that the next new worry is not the deficit, but inflation. Investors are concerned
about the increase in the core rate of inflation. The collapse of the Doha
trade round will ensure even higher farm prices and the potential return of
the protectionist policies of the thirties. We believe that like the current
bull market in hard commodities, higher energy prices and the changing weather
has resulted in a rundown in inventories and agricultural prices have edged
up. We might be able to switch from our SUVs, but we cannot skip a meal. Gold
is the ultimate hedge against inflation and is likely to outperform most other
assets.
Gold Stocks' Lack of Performance
Traditionally, gold stocks and bullion have moved together for much of the
economic cycle. But in this bull market, gold stocks have been the poor cousin
failing to keep pace with bullion's long run. Gold stocks provide not only
leverage but protection on the downside through diversification particularly
during bear markets. In the past three years bullion has increased 71 percent
while gold stocks have only gone up 52 percent during the same period. The
explosion of gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) is thought to be one of the
reasons for gold stocks' lack of performance. Another reason for gold stocks'
lack of performance is that for much of the bear market, gold companies were
interested more in survival than exploration and thus exploration budgets were
cutback. Since there were no drill turnings during the bear market, there were
no new discoveries.
Finally, gold stocks' lack of performance has frustrated both retail and institutional
investors alike. We believe that the chief factor is the lack of organic growth
and new discoveries. To date gold companies have harvested previous discoveries
and the cost of a discovery today has sky-rocketed. At one time the price tag
to bring the average 100,000 ounce discovery into production would cost about
$200 million. Today, most "100,000 ounce" projects would cost in excess of
$1 billion, which is very difficult to justify even at a $600 an ounce price
deck.
Consequently, in the last few years, the industry has instead consolidated
- takeovers the key driver instead of discoveries. Gold companies have taken
advantage of the low stock prices and there has been a major consolidation
in the gold industry (ounces are cheaper on Bay Street). While an important
variable for relative performance between bullion and gold stocks are the gold
companies' growth prospects, the consolidation means that there are just even
fewer investment vehicles today. We believe that the period of equity underperformance
will end when gold surpasses the $800 peak. Only then, will CNBC and Business
Week herald the new dawn of gold stocks' arrival. Consequently we would buy
a package of junior and mid-cap gold stocks.
Companies
Agnico-Eagle Mines Ltd
Agnico-Eagle's LaRonde mine in Quebec reported a great quarter due in part
to strong base metal prices. If one includes the byproduct credits for zinc
and silver, Agnico-Eagle produces gold at zero cost. Agnico's cash balance
now stands in excess of $400 million, which is sufficient to finance the
development at Kittila in Finland, Goldex and Lapa project in Quebec, and
the fast track funding of Pinos Altos in Mexico. Agnico-Eagle expects these
projects will boost the current production rate of 250,000 ounces to somewhere
around 750,000 ounces in the next 3 to 4 years. We have no doubts that Agnico
can achieve these levels, thus the company's shares are undervalued and should
be purchased at current levels. Buy.
Barrick Gold Corporation
Barrick reported second quarter results of $0.53 per share, which was more
than the company earned all of last year. Equity gold production was 2.1
million ounces and Barrick should produce 8.7 million ounces this year at
a cash cost of $285 per ounce. Barrick also continued the consolidation trend
by making an all cash hostile bid for NovaGold Resources Inc and Pioneer
Metals Corporation in order to consolidate the ownership of Donlin Creek
and add Galore Creek. Of note, rather than purchase production ounces, Barrick
has acquired ounces in the ground, presumably to offset the loss of South
Deep in South Africa which we believe will be sold. Barrick also eliminated
Placer Dome's hedge book of 7.7 million ounces at a total cost of $1.8 billion.
Barrick thus holds 2.8 million ounces corporately but another 9.5 million
ounces is allocated to Pascua-Lama and Pueblo Viejo. The mark-to-market loss
on Barrick's hedges is a whopping $4.3 billion at the spot gold price $614
per ounce. While Barrick has accelerated the reduction of its hedge book,
the hedges remain its Achilles heel, and we expect Barrick to further accelerate
either deliveries or buybacks.
Barrick's other problem is showing a growth trend and thus we expect the company
to fast track the exciting development at Cortez Hill in Nevada. Barrick is
focusing on the Cortez Hill property and has allocated additional funds and
Cortez may rival Goldstrike in size. Barrick has two other major projects in
addition to Cortez Hill. Pueblo Viejo in the Dominican Republic is a tough
metallurgical problem and the company expects to spend in excess of a $1 billion
for autoclave and power plant facilities. Donlin Creek in Alaska is a massive
project and infrastructure will be the question mark. While Barrick has the
management and balance sheet, all of these projects will likely cost in excess
of $1 billion each to develop, thus Barrick's problem is like all the others,
how to fill the growth gap between now and when these mines come on stream.
Consequently, we expect Barrick to continue its acquisition trend, preferring
to buy ounces on Bay Street rather than spend the time and money to find the
next big deposit.
Bema Gold Corporation
Bema raised additional funding for its flagship, high-grade gold-silver deposit,
Kupol in northern Siberia. Bema's results were disappointing in the quarter,
producing almost 80,000 ounces for a drop of almost 9,000 ounces due to shortfalls
at Petrex in South Africa and Refugio which just came on stream this year.
Bema is expected to offload Petrex and concentrate its efforts by developing
up Kupol's 5 million plus ounces. While Cerro Casale in Chile is one of the
world's largest underdeveloped copper/gold deposits, the price tag and modest
IRR relegates it as a "hidden asset" at this time. We continue to recommend
Bema shares for its growth profile and suitable acquisition tidbit for one
of the majors.
Centerra Gold
Centerra's results were weaker than expected. In addition, the company is only
now releasing the damage at the key flagship Kuptor deposit in Kyrgyzstan
where a pit wall collapsed, resulting in a drastic cutback of next year's
production. Centerra's main mine will have to undergo new development plans
and thus next year's production is iffy. We would switch Centerra into Agnico-Eagle
or Kinross where the growth prospects are better defined. Centerra has a
great balance sheet but until the development plans are better known, it
is dead money.
Crystallex International Corporation
Crystallex floated a small share issue which should be enough funds until March
of next year. Crystallex has been waiting for the all important final Environmental
Permit which is somehow caught up in Venezuela's bureaucracy. We expect that
the permit will be granted and the noise about the new Mining Act has no
applicability to Crystallex since it already enjoys a concession already
signed with the Venezuelan government. Thus the new mining law, will not
have an impact on Crystallex. Crystallex's key asset is the almost 14 million
plus ounce gold deposit in Las Cristinas in Bolivar State. We believe that
this is one of the few remaining world-class deposits left to be developed.
As such, we continue to believe that once the permit is granted, there will
be a heated auction for Crystallex at a takeout double the current price.
The current production plans remain that Crystallex should produce 300,000
ounces a year, and could begin production within 12 to 18 months of being granted
the permit. Crystallex has already ordered equipment, the runway is paved and
the company is dressed up and waiting for the party to begin. Crystallex shares
have been depressed as investors have become impatient and frustrated with
the lack of permit. We believe that the current weakness affords an excellent
purchasing opportunity and continue to recommend purchase.
Kinross Gold Corporation
Kinross reported an excellent quarter, producing 385,000 ounces in the second
quarter. Profits in the quarter was a whopping $0.19 a share or $65.6 million
up from a loss of $16.4 million a year. More important, Kinross continues
to accelerate development by allocating an additional half a billion dollars
to the Paracutu gold project in Brazil. Kinross' Paracutu's annually gold
output is expected to increase from the current 200,000 ounces to approximately
550,000 ounces by 2009. Acquired by Bob Buchan, Paracutu is Kinross' major
asset. Recent development drilling continues to show excellent growth in
potential resources and reserves. Meanwhile, production at the Refugio joint
venture in Chile, achieved its target rate, and that mine was a contributor
in this quarter. Kinross should produce 1.4 million ounces this year at a
cash cost of $305 per ounce. At long last, Kinross has filed documentation
to take in Crown Resources and the Buckhorn deposit will add to Kinross'
results. Kinross will produce almost 1.5 million unhedged ounces next year.
We continue to believe that the company will be an attractive tidbit for
one of the majors and/or Kinross could be a major player in the consolidation
game with its array of assets. While the shares have done well recently,
we continue to recommend purchase. We caution however, that the company has
reviewed just about every deal on Bay Street and has yet to pull the trigger.
While the company has been overly cautious, we believe that it is just a
matter of time before the company takes its first big step (since the alternative
is for Kinross to be gobbled up).
Newmont Mining Corporation
Newmont should produce between 5.9 and 6.2 million ounces this year plus a
quarter of a billion pounds of copper. Newmont too doubled its profits in
the second quarter to $161 million. Newmont however has not had a good year,
with government problems in Uzbekistan, Indonesia and South America. Newmont
must feel as if someone is putting a pin through a Newmont voodoo doll as
it fights governments in various jurisdictions. Newmont last year sold 123,000
ounces of gold from the Zarafshan/Newmont joint venture in western Uzbekistan,
but this June, the government declared the joint venture bankrupt over the
failure to pay $48 million in back taxes. This comes after Newmont had environmental
difficulties in Indonesia, problems with Gabriel in Romania and headaches
in Peru. Newmont has been very successful through the merchant banking (Franco-Nevada)
side of the business and the sale of Harker Holloway is expected shortly.
However with $1.5 billion of cash Newmont is in need of additional development
prospects and Aquarius in Nevada does not fit the bill. Newmont has been
cautious, and the company appears to be more interested in harvesting rather
than growing. We like the shares here, but we prefer the growth of the midcaps.
Click
to open larger image in new window:

Analyst Disclosure
| Company Name |
Trading Symbol |
*Exchange |
Disclosure code |
| Barrick Gold |
ABX |
T |
1 |
| Bema Gold |
BGO |
T |
1 |
| Crystallex |
KRY |
T |
1,5 |
| St. Andrew Goldfields |
SAS |
T |
5 |
Disclosure Key: 1=The Analyst, Associate or member of
their household owns the securities of the subject issuer. 2=Maison Placements
Canada Inc. and/or affiliated companies beneficially own more than 1% of any
class of common equity of the issuers. 3=<Employee name> who is an officer
or director of Maison Placements Canada Inc. or it's affiliated companies serves
as a director or advisory Board Member of the issuer. 4=In the previous 12
months a Maison Analyst received compensation from the subject company. 5=Maison
Placements Canada Inc. has managed co-managed or participated in an offering
of securities by the issuer in the past 12 months. 6=Maison Placements Canada
Inc. has received compensation for investment banking and related services
from the issuer in the past 12 months. 7=Maison is making a market in an equity
or equity related security of the subject issuer. 8=The analyst has recently
paid a visit to review the material operations of the issuer. 9=The analyst
has received payment or reimbursement from the issuer regarding a recent visit.
T-Toronto; V-TSX Venture; NQ-NASDAQ; NY-New York Stock Exchange