Dear Subscribers,
Before we begin our commentary, I would first like to thank David Korn - fellow
newsletter author of "The Retirement
Advisor" and author of the site Begininvesting.com -
for inviting me as a guest commentator in his market newsletter this week.
David has asked me to write a little tidbit on the "Yen Carry Trade" for his
subscribers. Also, I have asked David for a "return favor" next week - as I
will be out for business in Chicago from Sunday morning to Monday evening,
and therefore would not have time to write a full commentary. Look for a
copy of David's newsletter in your email inbox next weekend.
For those that are near retirement or who are retired, David Korn, Kirk Lindstrom,
and I have also published a monthly financial newsletter catered to folks in
this age group, should you be interested. This set of newsletters is more focused
on long-term portfolio management issues as well as other financial management
or planning issues. Our third issue has just been published. For those would
like a sample copy, you can download our inaugural copy at no cost at the following
link.
Let us now do an update on the two most recent signals in our DJIA Timing
System:
1st signal entered: 50% long position on September 7th at 11,385, giving us
a gain of 891.32 points
2nd signal entered: Additional 50% long position on September 25th at 11,505
giving us a gain of 771.32 points
I hope everyone has had a nice week. For those who had been wishing for a
reprieve from the volatility and the gyrations in the financial markets, you
definitely got your wish last week, as - coming off another 90% downside day
on Monday, the stock market recovered and experienced a 90% upside day on Tuesday.
Not only that, but the world's stock markets and currency markets recovered
as well, as the Yen sold off and as gold recovered from its abrupt slide over
the last few weeks.
More encouragingly, there were no hedge fund "blowups" during the latest crisis
- despite the intensity in selling on February 27th (the NYSE ARMS Index closed
at 15.77 that day - the highest reading since the 30.76 reading on September
26, 1955 - the Monday after President Eisenhower's weekend heart attack). Moreover,
there were only six prior instances of an ARMS reading above 15 since January
1940 - with one of them coming during the Fall of France, two of them during
1943 (when it seemed like the Allies were losing World War II), and two more
during 1946 when the 1942 to 1946 cyclical bull market was in the midst of
topping out. For comparison purposes, the NYSE ARMS Index hit a level of 14.07
during Black Monday, on October 19, 1987.
Following is a chart showing the ten-day moving average of the NYSE ARMS Index
from January 1949 to the present:

As one can see from the above chart, the selling that we endured on the U.S.
stock market during February 27th and the following four days was one of the
most intense in history. Not only was this apparent in the U.S. stock market,
but all around the world as well as the major global market indices plunged.
At the height of the selling, money managers in Asia were remarking that they
have not experienced this kind of selling intensity since the height of the
Asia Crisis in October 1997.
Again - more encouragingly - there were no significant hedge fund blowups.
Nor were there any significant "forced sellers" or derivative problems as far
as we could tell. The cause of the February 27th plunge in stock prices is
still unknown, but what is clear is the following:
-
As I have mentioned before (see our "MarketThoughts'
Road Map for the Next 12 to 24 Months" post in our discussion forum),
many hedge funds over the last six months had capitulated" and just tried
to ride either the MSCI World Index and the S&P 500 in order to goose
up their returns. In other words, they were really increasing their "betas" and
disguising them as "alphas." They had to - since many "absolute return
strategies" were not working out. Spreads were at all-time lows. The
carry trade was getting very dangerous, as the Yen were at all-time lows
against the Euro and against the dollar on a purchasing power parity
basis. The huge increase in exposure to both the S&P 500 and to the
MSCI World index by hedge funds over the last six months has been well-documented
by Goldman, Lehman, and GaveKal. Given the "trigger-happy" condition
of many hedge funds, a quick correction in the S&P 500 and other
global market indices was inevitable sooner or later.
-
In both the short-term and the intermediate term, both the world's stock
markets and the Yen carry trade were getting stretched. Again, a correction
was to come sooner or later.
-
Finally, many "bad news of the day" events were coming to the forefront
- bad news such as the problems in the subprime industry, the volatility
in the Chinese stock market, a continuing slowdown of the U.S. economy,
and so forth.
Make no mistake: I am not trying to downplay the events over the last two
weeks, but so far, this author has not seen any classic signs of an impending
top in the U.S. stock market - or any other major stock market across the Atlantic
or Pacific, for that matter. Sure, the troubles in the subprime industry is
a warning that "trees don't grow to the sky" - but typical cyclical bull markets
have survived harsher blows before - ranging from the San Francisco Earthquake
of 1906, the Korean War, the 1994 collapse of the bond market, the 1997 Asian
Crisis, and so forth. As a matter of fact, the recent "shot across the bow" presents
a good warning to both investors and hedge funds about risk taking and management
- and should actually serve to lengthen the duration of the cyclical bull market
rather than shorten it.
As for the Yen carry trade, readers should be reminded here that the structural
underpinnings of the Yen carry trade remains sound. That is, the biggest participant
of the Yen carry trade remains the Japanese retail investor - as he or she
continues to seek out investment opportunities around the world, given the
lack of investment opportunities in his/her home country. Make no mistake:
The financial liberalization of the Japanese economy is only just starting.
One of the consequences (which we are already witnessing) is that both Japanese
institutional and retail investors have continued to adopt a more global mandate
in their investments. From a recent Bloomberg article:
Japanese mutual funds have boosted purchases of overseas assets to about
40 percent of the total from about 8 percent in 2002, according to Investment
Trust Association data. Japanese mutual funds now have about $244 billion
of assets denominated in foreign currencies, including $98 billion in the
U.S. dollar.
There may be more outflows because Japanese households keep 51 percent
of their savings in cash or bank accounts, compared with 13 percent for savers
in the U.S., said Brian Garvey, senior currency strategist with State Street
Global Markets in Boston, one of the world's largest custodians of investor
assets with $11.9 trillion.
Finally, with over $2 trillion in the Japanese Postal savings accounts - there
is still a lot of funds waiting to be invested. Ever since the Japanese real
estate and stock market bubble collapsed in 1990, "capital conservation" has
been the game - but with the first uptick in real estate prices in Japan last
year, and with the Chinese government also adopting a more global asset allocation
strategy going forward, one can most probably bet that the Japanese isn't far
behind as well. After a hiatus of over 15 years, a more risk-seeking Japanese
populace will fundamentally change the meaning of global investing - weakening
the Yen further in the process.
I now want to use the rest of the commentary to discuss the latest 4Q 2006 "Flow
of Funds" data as published by the Federal Reserve - and what this may entail
for the U.S. economy and the U.S. stock market. Let us first discuss the balance
sheet of U.S. households - starting with a chart showing the absolute amount
of net worth of U.S. households vs. their asset-to-liability ratio from 1Q
1952 to 4Q 2006:

As mentioned on the above chart, total U.S. household net worth rose another
7.4% on a year-over-year basis to an all-time high of $55.6 trillion as of
the end 2006. While this latest appreciation has not been as brisk as the average
appreciation from the third quarter of 2003 and onwards (it has averaged nearly
10% since 3Q 2003), it is still very respectable - especially given the slowdown
in the U.S. housing market and the slower-than-expected GDP growth of 2.2%
during the fourth quarter of 2006. More importantly, this latest appreciation
was accompanied by a rise in the asset-to-liability ratio from 5.16 to 5.18
- as the growth of home mortgage debt slowed to 8.9% in 2006, down from a 13.8%
rate in 2005. However small it may be, this latest decline in the leverage
of households' balance sheets is definitely a welcome sign. Note, however,
that the secular decline in the asset-to-liability ratio of U.S. households
remains intact.
Unless we experience an across-the-board decline in U.S. home prices and unless
gasoline rises to $4 a gallon, the secular story of the U.S. consumer remains
intact for now. Moreover, the following chart (showing the amount of equities
and mutual funds held by U.S. households as a percentage of their total and
financial assets) is telling us that the cyclical bull market in the U.S. is
nowhere close to exhaustion just yet:

While the stock market can and will do anything in the short-run (and sometimes
even the intermediate term as well), the history of the stock market suggests
that a cyclical bull market will only die on "exhaustion." That is, it will
not end until all the marginal buyers are exhausted - whether these marginal
buyers are your "widows and orphans," your shoeshine boys, or whoever that
has no place in being in the stock market in the first place. Among the classic
indicators of potential exhaustion are valuations, the amount of margin debt
outstanding, and of course, the amount of equities or mutual funds held by
U.S. households as a percentage of their total and financial assets (note that
while sentiment is a great bottom indicator, it has never really worked as
a "topping" indicator). Given that the amount of equities held by households
(as a percentage of their total and financial assets) is only at its 54-year
average - there is still a lot of potential for further accumulation of U.S.
and international stocks by U.S. households. The U.S. cyclical bull market
lives on...
More follows for subscribers...