Irrationally Supersized

By: Erik Swarts | Mon, Mar 26, 2012
Print Email

After completing our annual pilgrimage to those sucrose-laden shores of Disney World last week, I can attest that the American consumer is both present in droves and larger than ever.


And although I reluctantly signed on for the Disney experience many years ago against the better judgement of my uptight (i.e. WASP) upbringing to interactive social vacations with the masses (see - Big Fat Greek Wedding - character of Ian Miller), I did marry into an orthodox and gregarious (a rare but loving combination) Mediterranean family who finds great joys in experiencing the parks many amusements from sunrise to well past sunset. Needless to say, and very much like the movie - I am a convert. With that said, I am quite happy to be home from what inevitably becomes our own version of the Amazing Race - gluttony edition. If nothing else, Disney is a shocking anthropologic mirror to peer into. With attendance in Magic Kingdom alone topping more than 17 million visitors a year (highest in the world), it presents guests with a rare and unique cross section of consumerism - specifically, American consumerism.

Although it's exceedingly unscientific and biased, due to the fact that the large ones tend to catch your eye faster than the svelte ones - it's becoming painful, both literally and figuratively - to walk the parks and watch the American population become increasingly obese and unkempt. Further exemplifying this is the now burgeoning cottage industry of off-site scooter rentals that caters to this ever growing demographic. All is needed is a quick phone call to the local Orlando chariot salesman and for a reasonable fee they will drop a sturdy scooter off at your hotel or park of choice.

Have no fear - ScootOrlando is here...

Getting back to the business of the markets, I have my doubts on whether the exuberance witnessed in the endless waist lines or in the general consumption index of plastic figurines is a harbinger for another irrational trip down memory lane. However, the SPX finds itself once again within striking distance of the Meridian threshold (currently crayoned ~ 1441), that has in the past differentiated exuberance, both the irrational (96-00) and rational (03-07) variety - from everything else.

The Meridian Market Theory - SPX (Monthly)
Larger Image

It should be duly noted to market participants that up until February, the SPX was very much following (both structurally speaking and contrasted with momentum) the previous occasions (post 1987 and 1994) where the tape was rejected by the Meridian. Since then, it has audibled from that script quite considerably - both in terms of the duration and magnitude of the retracement rally. While the market was initially in lock-step (see Here) with the post 1987 crash analog, and very closely following the RSI pivots of the 1994 market (see Here), the current tape has simply failed to correct for anything more than a few sessions since early December. In essence, it has displayed even more exuberance than both comparable rallies that took place within a secular bull market. The old saying on the breathtaking, albeit volume less nature of a bear market rally comes to mind.

Some things to consider here.

There are parallels with the current market to the 1994/1995 time period that go beyond simply the structure and occurrence of the Meridian rejection. I suppose they would fall more into similarities and contrasts (within the charts) in the business cycle - although I use that phrase extremely loosely here since they have been "stealing from Peter to pay Paul" since the financial crisis began.

As evidenced in the chart below of the S&P 500 Banks Industry Group (GSPBK), both periods are subsequent to a major financial crisis in the banking sector. With respect to duration, structure and momentum - they have trended along very similar lines. Both timeframes have occurred where the sector has consolidated the considerable gains out of the crisis low. As noted in the chart, the consolidation range was broken in 1995 when the broader market breached the Meridian and ushered in what we know refer to as irrational exuberance.

EKG of a Boom & Bust - BAnking Sector GSPBK (Weekly)
Larger Image

Of course the primary difference when comparing the current recovery to the 1994/1995 time period is that the current rally is taking place within a secular bear market. This is clearly on display when contrasting the SPX with the Bank:SPX ratio.

Larger Image

Could another April breach of the Meridian be in the market's future?

Anything is possible (especially with a FED chairman bent on slowing the U.S. dollar's ascent), but from this perspective, and very much like the growing assemblage of my fellow American's - the current market is perhaps just irrationally supersized than exuberant here.

As always - stay frosty - lean and clean.

As a postscript and considering I have been away "vacationing" for the past week, I wanted to thank Alan Abelson again for mentioning my work in Barron's last week (see Here). As someone who appreciates both his mastery as a wordsmith and insightful curator of market research, it's always a treat and humbling experience to hear from Mr. Abelson.



Erik Swarts

Author: Erik Swarts

Erik Swarts
Market Anthropology

Although I am an active trader, I have always taken a broad perspective when approaching the markets. I respect the Big Picture and attempt to place each piece of information within its appropriate context and timeframe. I have found that without this approach, there is very little understanding of ones expectations in the market and an endless potential for risk.

I am not a stock picker - but trade the broader market itself in varying timeframes. I want to know which way the prevailing wind is blowing, where the doldrums can be expected and where the shoals will likely rise. I will not claim to know which vessel is the fastest or most comfortable for passage - but I can read the charts and know the risks.

I am not a salesperson for the market and its many wares. I observe it, contextualize its moving parts - both visible and discrete - and interpret.

I practice Market Anthropology - Welcome to my notes.

Erik Swarts is not a registered investment advisor. Under no circumstances should any content be used or interpreted as a recommendation for any investment, trade or approach to the markets. Trading and investing can be hazardous to your wealth. Any investment decisions must in all cases be made by the reader or by his or her registered investment advisor. This is strictly for educational and informational purposes only. All opinions expressed by Mr. Swarts are subject to change without notice, and the reader should always obtain current information and perform their own due diligence before making any investment or trading decision.

Copyright © 2011-2016 Erik Swarts

All Images, XHTML Renderings, and Source Code Copyright ©