Milton Friedman - How Politicians Can Cause Another Great Depression

By: Larry Cyna | Wed, Sep 19, 2012
Print Email

The US Debate over Quantitative Easing

We have an interesting debate going on in the US Presidential campaign. On one side are people claiming that government handouts are ruining America and the government must immediately stop incurring debt, and go to a balanced budget.

On the other other side are people claiming that the economy needs boosting and the government must be cautious, but at the same time must provide more liquidity to the economy when needed. The result is the Fed buying more bonds and incurring more debt.

A Debate Resting on Slogans and Lack of Understanding

The debate is somewhat ludicrous as it relies on 'catch phrases' and slogans, rather than an analysis of the facts and an understanding of economics and history. Democracy involves trying to tell people who have only a passing interest in the detail of the debate, why they should vote for one view or another. Why and how democracy works is a mystery, but it does in spite of economic views that are sometimes quite odd.

I am grateful that when a President is elected, no matter how ludicrous his campaign promises may have been, and no matter how ignorant he/she may be, the reliance on educated and noted advisers usually brings some reality to the views and opinions of that newly elected President.

Milton Friedman - the Noted Economist - Video From 1977

Let me begin by suggesting the reader look on YouTube for the Milton Friedman speech given on his University lecture tour of 1977. It is a bit long, and gives his viewpoint on five different topics, yet the listener need only hear his views on the second topic.

It is his opinion that The Great Depression of the 1930s was directly caused by well meaning politicians who completely misunderstood the function of government, and what the availability of money and credit means to a society.

He states unequivocally that the The Great Depression was caused by Government, by the Federal Reserve. In order to combat what was perceived by the government as excessive debt, which in the opinion of the Fed at that time had caused a recession, the Federal Reserve embarked on a strict policy of reducing debt and and reducing the availability of money in circulation, in order to bring normality back to the USA.

Quoting Milton Friedman, "from 1929 to 1933, the total amount of money in circulation declined by 1/3 and the total number of banks went down by 1/3".

The effect of this was to ensure that economic activity was dramatically curtailed. In simple terms, in order to reduce debt, the government reduced economic activity, reduced spending, reduced jobs, reduced, reduced and reduced. If it had not reduced the amount of money in circulation, the great depression would never had occurred. It would have instead been a mild downturn.

The great Depression was caused by the failure of government to provide sufficient money to the system according to Milton Friedman.

Listening to this noted economist, one must wonder about the policies that are again being promoted today as the cure to the nation's ills. It seems as if enough time passes, the pain inflicted previously is forgotten. What short memories we all have. If reducing the debt by drastically cutting money supply and expenditures caused a world wide depression that lasted from 1929 until the start of WWII then, why would our politicians now attempt to apply the same idiotic cure.

The Reagan Years & Spending Restraint

Another slogan being promoted, is the Conservatism of Ronald Reagan, under whom prosperity soared in the USA. What fond memories we are asked to remember. Except, what is conveniently not mentioned, is that the national debt soared under Ronald Reagan to the trillion dollar level for the first time in history. Ronald Reagan did not reduce government debt. He dramatically increased the nation's debt. The great Republican dramatically increased debt.

Dennis Gartman Speaking at the New York Hard Asset Show 2012

A Keynote Address was from Mr Dennis Gartman. He stated that there was a parallel to 1933 when the US decided to deal with a recession by cutting spending, reducing debt and removing currency from circulation. The result created The Great Depression.

Mr. Gartman felt that if politicians in the USA followed a policy today of taking similar action, of cutting spending, of reducing debt drastically, and reducing the amount of currency in circulation, the result again would be disastrous.

The Canadian Example

Canada is now regarded worldwide as a shining example of fiscal conservatism. The financial crisis of 2008 did not greatly affect Canada. Housing prices held firm and economic activity reduced only slightly.

In the 1980s, Canada was spending far more than its government revenues allowed for. The debt was becoming enormous. The feeling was that a fiscal default was coming. However, the Canadian government did not reduce spending significantly. It reduced spending by a very small amount, but stopped the annual increase in spending. The budget continued in deficit, but new spending was curtailed gradually year after year, until a balanced budget was achieved. The increase in the economy, combined with a debt that stopped growing, gradually brought matters into balance.

The total national debt was never really reduced. It was just that its significance became less and less relevant as the economy grew. As a percentage of GDP, the debt became less and less of a percentage, until when the financial crisis of 2008 hit, the debt was insignificant. It was till roughly the same amount as it was in the 1980s, it just had not increased in the intervening period.

Small inflation over a long period does that. It reduces the significance of an amount of money over time. Canada is a perfect example of how to deal with excesses of debt. This is the example that the Europeans currently are attempting to follow..

Politicians in the USA should pay attention to the obvious way to solve the problem.



Larry Cyna

Author: Larry Cyna

Lawrence J. Cyna, CA

Larry Cyna

Larry Cyna, CA, is CEO and Portfolio Advisor to Cymorfund, a boutique hedge fund. He expresses his insights several times a week on his blog and offers a free newsletter which can be subscribed to here.

Mr. Cyna is an accomplished investor in the Canadian public markets for over 20 years, and has managed significant portfolios. He is a financing specialist for private and public companies, and has expertise in real estate and debt obligations. He has assisted private companies accessing the public markets, has been a founding director of public companies and is a strategic consultant to selected clientele.

He is and has been a director, a senior officer and on the Advisory Board of a number of TSX and TSXV public companies in the mining, resource, technology and telecommunications sectors, and the Founding Director of two CPC's with qualifying transactions in mining and minerals. He was an honorary director of the Rotman School of Management MBA IMC program, has completed the Canadian Securities Institute Canadian Securities Course & Institute Conduct and Practices Handbook Course, was a former Manager under contract to an Investment Manager at BMO Nesbitt Burns, a roster mediator under the Ontario Mandatory Mediation Program, Toronto, a member of the Institute of Corporate Directors of Ontario, a member of the Upper Canada Dispute Resolution Group, and the Ontario Bar Association, Alternate Dispute Resolution section.

He obtained his designation as a Chartered Accountant in Ontario in 1971 and was the recipient of the Founder's Prize for academic achievement together with a cash reward. He became a CPA in the State of Illinois, USA in 1999 under IQEX with a grade of 92%. He is a Member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Ontario and the Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants.

He holds certificates in Advanced ADR & in Civil Justice in Ontario, Faculty of Law, University of Windsor, certificate in Dispute Resolution from the Ontario Institute of Chartered Accountants. Previous accomplishments are Manager of Cymor Risk Consultants LP specializing in Risk Management Assessment; CEO of Cyna & Associates specializing in mediation and ADR; Founder & Senior Partner of Cyna & Co, Chartered Accountants, a fully licensed and accredited public accountancy firm with international affiliations; and was a partner in a large public accountancy firm.

Mr. Cyna is well known in the Canadian Investing community. He attends presentations given by public companies to the industry on a daily basis.. These presentations are intended by the various hosting companies to present their inside story for the purpose of attracting funding, or of making parties more interested in acquiring shares of those companies. Being in constant communication in this manner keeps Mr. Cyna deeply involved in the current market and leads to numerous investment opportunities.

Mr. Cyna is currently a Director of Argentum Silver Corporation and Telehop Communications Inc.

Copyright © 2012-2013 Lawrence J. Cyna

All Images, XHTML Renderings, and Source Code Copyright ©