Vigilantes: A Balanced Portfolio's Worst Nightmare

By: Chris Ciovacco | Wed, May 7, 2014
Print Email

What Is A Bond Market Vigilante?

Bond Market Vigilante

Before we can move on to a hypothetical example of a difficult period for stock-and-bond-only portfolios, it is important to understand the concept of bond market vigilantes. According to the The Roosevelt Institute:

A bond vigilante is a bond market investor who protests a country's fiscal policies by selling off its bonds and refusing to buy them. This happens when the bond investors perceive the policy to be inflationary, and can act as a check on a government that is over-spending. The proof of vigilante action is high interest rates, as yields rise when investors perceive risk; this makes a government's cost of borrowing rise.

Bond vigilantes can also come out of the woodwork to protest low-interest rate policies from the Fed. Bond vigilantes worry that excessive money printing will eventually spark inflation, which erodes the purchasing power of interest payments made to bond holders.

Are You Safe With A Balanced Portfolio?

A stock-and-bond-only strategy, often referred to as a balanced portfolio, could have trouble in certain corrective periods. For example, what happens if the next bear market is caused by the Fed losing control of interest rates? The Fed has artificially suppressed rates for years. If all the printed money in the system eventually leads to inflation, bond vigilantes could sell bonds, causing interest rates to spike. Rising interest rates can be a drag on economic growth. Under that scenario, both stocks and bonds could get hit hard simultaneously. A balanced portfolio has no place to hide when stocks and bonds are both declining in value.

A Spike In Rates, Is A Spike In Rates

Can stocks and bond fall in unison? Sure they can. It becomes more expensive to borrow as interest rates rise, which can impact corporate profit margins. The negative impact of higher rates on economic growth comes regardless of the "why" behind a sell-off in bonds. Therefore, any period in history when bonds and stocks sold off simultaneously can provide a glimpse of what a bear market caused by the Fed losing control of rates might look like.

1994: Rates Went Up And Stocks Went Down

The Vanguard Balanced Index (VBINX) basically invests in a mix of 60% stocks and 40% bonds, meaning it can serve as a proxy for a balanced portfolio. The chart below shows the performance of the fund during a 1994 spike in interest rates.

VBINX 1994 Chart

Manipulated Markets Mean Higher Risk

When we use the term manipulated we are not talking about Area 51-like scenarios or complex conspiracies. The Fed manipulates/distorts markets all the time. When you artificially suppress interest rates, it impacts the pricing mechanisms of both the stock and bond markets, along with countless others.

TNX 1982-2014 Monthly Chart

The chart above is like a spring that has been compressed by Fed policy. If inflation expectations pick up in the coming years, the spring could be released by the bond vigilantes.

Investment Implications - Fixed Allocations Can Be Dangerous

Could a static mix of stocks and bonds perform well in the coming years? Sure it could. Could the same balanced portfolio get hammered under the inflation/vigilante/Fed-losing-control-of-rates scenario outlined above? It is well within reason, meaning the risk is something to think about.

Wait a minute...aren't you basically holding stocks (SPY), bonds (TLT), and cash right now? Yes, we have a mixed allocation to align with the current indecisive market profile. The difference between our market model and a balanced portfolio is we make adjustments as conditions change. If stocks and bonds become unattractive, the model can allocate to cash, currencies, commodities, precious metals, etc. We have places to run and hide. A balanced portfolio does not.

Can We Stock Pick Our Way Out?

A fair question may be can't we just invest in individual stocks during the next bear market or stock-pick our way to success? It is possible, but very difficult to do in the real world since the vast majority of stocks decline in value during a bear market. For example, could we have invested in blue chips in the wake of the dot-com bust and minimized the damage? For the answer, see the chart below.

DOW 2002-2004 Daily Chart



Chris Ciovacco

Author: Chris Ciovacco

Chris Ciovacco
Ciovacco Capital Management

Chris Ciovacco

Chris Ciovacco is the Chief Investment Officer for Ciovacco Capital Management, LLC. More on the web at

All material presented herein is believed to be reliable but we cannot attest to its accuracy. Investment recommendations may change and readers are urged to check with their investment counselors and tax advisors before making any investment decisions. Opinions expressed in these reports may change without prior notice. This memorandum is based on information available to the public. No representation is made that it is accurate or complete. This memorandum is not an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell the securities mentioned. The investments discussed or recommended in this report may be unsuitable for investors depending on their specific investment objectives and financial position. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The price or value of the investments to which this report relates, either directly or indirectly, may fall or rise against the interest of investors. All prices and yields contained in this report are subject to change without notice. This information is based on hypothetical assumptions and is intended for illustrative purposes only. THERE ARE NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED, AS TO ACCURACY, COMPLETENESS, OR RESULTS OBTAINED FROM ANY INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS ARTICLE.

Ciovacco Capital Management, LLC is an independent money management firm based in Atlanta, Georgia. CCM helps individual investors and businesses, large & small; achieve improved investment results via research and globally diversified investment portfolios. Since we are a fee-based firm, our only objective is to help you protect and grow your assets. Our long-term, theme-oriented, buy-and-hold approach allows for portfolio rebalancing from time to time to adjust to new opportunities or changing market conditions.

Copyright © 2006-2016 Chris Ciovacco

All Images, XHTML Renderings, and Source Code Copyright ©