Weekly Wrap-up: Unwinding the Yen carry Trade

By: Adam Oliensis | Fri, Mar 9, 2007
Print Email

Dear Speculators,

The following article was first published at The Agile Trader on Sunday, March 4, 2007.

In 2007 the Agile Trader Index Options Service has closed trades for gross gains of +31%, +15%, +8%, +34%, +122%, and +64% for a total of +274% in position gains with no losing trades. In 2006 the System grossed +682% in position gains. (Of course, gross portfolio performance depends upon asset allocation.) If you would like to read more about The Agile Trader Index Options Service, CLICK HERE. And if you would like a free 1-month trial to the service (offered for a limited time), CLICK HERE and then click SUBSCRIBE.

In 2007 Agile Trader Index Futures Service has netted 88% in position gains on 7 winning trades with no losses. If you would like a free one-month trial to the Futures Service please click HERE.


Two weeks ago I wrote:

I suspect that in the context of an inverted yield curve (and especially of a steepening inversion) the market's PE is unlikely to continue to expand as it has since last summer. Note that since '03 there has been a strong correlation between the sinking market PE and the flattening (and then inverting) yield curve. At present PE is rising as the trend in the yield curve resists doing likewise. I continue to suspect that that divergence is unsustainable.

The above was written in reference to the following chart when the market PE (blue line) was peaking at 15.2. It has since sunk (abruptly) to 14.5.

I further elaborated:

Unless the bond market starts discounting accelerating economic growth I suspect that the "cap" on PE will be not too far above where it is now.

The temptation exists to poo-poo the inversion of the Yield Curve as "different this time." But at some point in the not-too-distant future bond and stock investors are probably going to have to come to some sort of closer agreement about what the prospects indeed are for the economy. A condition in which the bond market is discounting +2.36% real GDP and in which the stock market is discounting earnings growth that's a 3.3 times greater…well, that's very likely unsustainable.

The time is right for the market to "take stock" of these factors.

Lest you think that my main interest is in patting myself on the back for being reasonably timely with the warning, while I was cautious I did NOT anticipate an adjustment as swift and severe as the one that the equity markets (and indeed virtually all financial markets) underwent last week.

Last week we looked at this weekly chart of the SPX (since updated with last week's long red candle):

And I wrote:

The (pink) wedge is a potentially bearish formation as the shallower slope of the upper limit of the wedge represents diminished buying enthusiasm at higher levels. And if the wedge breaks to the downside, especially after a multi-month advance such as the one that has been enjoyed since July, then profit-taking can become compelling motivation for selling.

But, honestly, I did not think that we would set about retracing almost 38% of the market's July-February advance in a week's time.

So, what's going on? Well, for one thing, (and this may be the primary catalyst of the wicked sell-down), it appears that some comments by a Japanese finance minister about the size of the Yen Carry Trade helped to trigger a panicky buying spree in the Japanese Yen. Which is to say, that the huge preponderance of borrowing in Yen (engendered by near-zero Japanese interest rates) to finance purchases of virtually all other sorts assets, of both the hard and paper varieties, began to unwind but fast.

This next chart plots the March futures in the SPX, the Japanese Yen, and the US Dollar.

As you can see, the past week's action is defined by an inverse correlation between the S&P Futures and the Yen; the S&P tanking while the Yen surged. While the declining Dollar does seem to be involved, it appears that the upsurge of the Yen is much more aggressively germane than the Dollar's decline. And that interpretation is borne out by the nasty decline in the Gold market as well. It's the panic to pay back borrowed/leveraged Yen for fear of that currency's further appreciation that has pushed all the financial markets lower. (If the primary factor were the dollar's decline, then Gold would likely be rising, not falling in Dollar terms.)

GLD, the ETF that tracks the price of Gold at 1/10 the price, declined 7.3% from Tuesday through Friday, from $68.33 to $63.34. Remarkably, investors were even selling Gold to buy Yen.

This global fear of the unwinding of the Yen Carry Trade (the borrowing of Yen to buy everything else) has caused the bond market to price in further-decelerating US economic growth.

The flight to quality pushed the yield on the 5-Yr Treasury down to 4.46% (the 10-Yr is just a bit higher at 4.51%).

The TIPS market is now discounting economic growth at something very close to 2% over the coming 5 years, down from 2.6% last autumn. And that fear of further-decelerating growth has raised our Equity Risk Premium (ERP, defined as the SPX's Forward Earnings Yield less the 10-Yr Treasury Yield -- 6.89% - 4.51% = 2.38%) up to a heightened level.

The long-term average ERP is near 0%. However, the median post-9/11 ERP is about 1.98%. So, while it is possible that ERP will get pushed higher, it is already at an extremely elevated level, in about the 87th percentile of all ERP readings since 1960.

That said, unless inflation is in double digits, it is extremely difficult to begin a bear market with ERP at the kind of lofty levels we're seeing now. This next chart provides a zoomed-out look at ERP plotted against the SPX on a logarithmic scale.

While it is always possible for a one-off crisis to tank the stock market hard on a short-term basis (in this case the potential exists for a liquidity crisis to occur if a sustained panic develops to unwind the Yen Carry Trade), or for unanticipated factors to profoundly damage the global economy, it looks more to me as though we are seeing a relatively minor adjustment that is coming at precisely the time that our cyclical charts anticipated it, albeit more suddenly and severely than we had expected.

Please recall that last week we showed the following chart.

And that we described our expectation that the red line (SPX annualized 2.5-year appreciation) would regress down toward the 8% level by the end of June. Well, last week the red line took a whopping big step down from 11.4% to 9.2%, covering almost 2/3 of the distance remaining on its journey from 13% to 8%.

So, is there something to worry about? You bet. We should all be worried about whether the lemmings run back into the Yen so furiously that they unbalance the global financial markets for more than just the short term. But we should also be aware that this would be an undesirable outcome for virtually everyone on the planet and that letting the situation get out of hand would be something that a lot of policy-makers across the globe would be working against. So, I suspect that we should still regard the "catastrophe" scenario as a low-odds one.

As things stand currently, the high-probability bet would still appear to be that a relatively virtuous economic cycle is intact and that, as per the chart above, we will tend to see positive performance from the SPX on a cyclical basis, at least into the latter part of this year, albeit with some choppiness between now and the summer.

Much of the work of this corrective phase has been done quickly. And bearishness is now running at a high level, as evidenced by the new all-time high in the Aggregate Put/Call Ratio 5-dma, which is a very informative contrarian indicator.

While it's a little tough to see on this long-term chart, extremely high levels on this indicator have a high correlation to local lows on the SPX.

Of course anything's possible. And it's possible that this time this indicator will fail to mark a tradable low. But the sudden, severe rise in pessimism, while at least somewhat warranted, also looks to be overdone.

We'll find out more about this market's mettle when we see how it reacts to last week's abrupt change of character. We would expect a bounce this coming week. If a bounce does not come, well, that would be a significant negative for the market's mid-term prospects. And if it does come, then we'll be gauging the quality of that bounce with all the measuring tools at our disposal.

Best regards and good trading!

 


 

Adam Oliensis

Author: Adam Oliensis

Adam Oliensis,
Editor The Agile Trader

IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES

ALL PERFORMANCE RESULTS ARE HYPOTHETICAL.

HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS HAVE MANY INHERENT LIMITATIONS, SOME OF WHICH ARE DESCRIBED BELOW. NO REPRESENTATION IS BEING MADE THAT ANY ACCOUNT WILL OR IS LIKELY TO ACHIEVE PROFITS OR LOSSES SIMILAR TO THOSE SHOWN. IN FACT, THERE ARE FREQUENTLY SHARP DIFFERENCES BETWEEN HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS AND THE ACTUAL RESULTS SUBSEQUENTLY ACHIEVED BY ANY PARTICULAR TRADING PROGRAM.

ONE OF THE LIMITATIONS OF HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS IS THAT THEY ARE GENERALLY PREPARED WITH THE BENEFIT OF HINDSIGHT. IN ADDITION, HYPOTHETICAL TRADING DOES NOT INVOLVE FINANCIAL RISK, AND NO HYPOTHETICAL TRADING RECORD CAN COMPLETELY ACCOUNT FOR THE IMPACT OF FINANCIAL RISK IN ACTUAL TRADING. FOR EXAMPLE, THE ABILITY TO WITHSTAND LOSSES OR ADHERE TO A PARTICULAR TRADING PROGRAM IN SPITE OF TRADING LOSSES ARE MATERIAL POINTS WHICH CAN ALSO ADVERSELY AFFECT ACTUAL TRADING RESULTS. THERE ARE NUMEROUS OTHER FACTORS RELATED TO THE MARKET IN GENERAL OR TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ANY SPECIFIC TRADING PROGRAM WHICH CANNOT BE FULLY ACCOUNTED FOR IN THE PREPARATION OF HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS AND ALL OF WHICH CAN ADVERSELY AFFECT ACTUAL TRADING RESULTS.

DOG DREAMS UNLIMITED INC.(DDUI), WHICH OWNS AND OPERATES THE AGILE TRADER, HAS HAD LITTLE OR NO EXPERIENCE IN TRADING ACTUAL ACCOUNTS FOR ITSELF OR FOR CUSTOMERS. BECAUSE THERE ARE NO ACTUAL TRADING RESULTS TO COMPARE TO THE HYPOTHETICAL RESULTS, CUSTOMERS SHOULD BE PARTICULARLY WARY OF PLACING UNDUE RELIANCE ON THESE HYPOTHETICAL PERFORMANCE RESULTS.

Trading commodity futures may involve large potential rewards, but also carries large potential risks. You must be aware of the risks and be willing to accept them in order to invest in the futures markets. Dont trade with money that you cannot afford to lose. The past performance of any trading system or methodology is not necessarily indicative of future results.

The Agile Trader and all individuals affiliated with The Agile Trader assume no responsibilities for your trading and investment results.

As a publisher of a financial newsletter of general and regular circulation, The Agile Trader cannot tender individual investment advice on the suitability and performance of your portfolio or specific investments. Refer to your registered investment adviser for individualized advice.

In making any investment decision, you will rely solely on your own review and examination of the facts and the records relating to such investments. Past performance of our recommendations is not an indication of future performance. The publisher shall have no liability of whatever nature in respect to any claims, damage, loss, or expense arising out of or in connection with the reliance by you on the contents of our Web site, any promotion, published material, alert, or update.

Trading commodity futures involves substantial risk of loss. DDUI and all individuals affiliated with DDUI assume no responsibilities for your trading and investment results.

Copyright © 2003-2010 The Agile Trader, LLC All rights reserved.

All Images, XHTML Renderings, and Source Code Copyright © Safehaven.com